Review: Taste of Hayward Event

Restaurant reviewer Philip McDonald attended the recent Taste of Hayward event in Downtown. Of the more than 12 establishments on offer, find out what stood out, what failed to impress, and which—if any—are worth a second visit.

Review: Taste of Hayward Event
A photograph of the Downtown Area by DT . If you want to see your neighborhood in a story, submit a photo today!

By Philip McDonald

On October 22nd, Janet and I attended the 2nd annual Taste Of Hayward celebration. For a fee ($38) different restaurants in Hayward offer samples to taste, and then you walk from restaurant to restaurant tasting what they offer that evening.

This year there were 25 participating restaurants, all Downtown. We started at the fountain area in front of city hall where we exchanged our receipts for a “passport”— a card with all the restaurants listed that we showed at each place.

The first restaurant was The Gurkha Kitchen an Indian/Nepalese/Himalayan Restaurant at 838 B Street. I’ve been there before and liked it. They served a dumpling, essentially a pot sticker with a sauce. It was good.

Dumpling from The Gurkha Kitchen

Across the street is SugarMama Sugarcane. They served two versions of cane juice: what the server called “the OG” and a flavored one. It is sugar cane juice—essentially sweet water. I asked the server what else they did and he said, “I don’t know, I’m just here for tonight.”

Afterward, I went to Erik’s Deli Cafe. I like Erik’s but that night they were dishing out what looked like chili. The passport said, “pesto pasta salad” but it looked like chili and I passed.

I bypassed Cold Stone Creamery—I like to keep my sweets till last—and went to Teriyaki City Grill instead. It's in the parking lot shared with Lucky and they offered grilled steak or chicken with a teriyaki sauce. I took the steak, which was cold. I don’t know if it is supposed to be but I didn’t ask as they had a lot of customers and seemed to be very popular. The teriyaki sauce would have been good on anything.

Butter Pecan was the next stop but I passed them for the same reason as Cold Stone. I have been to Butter Pecan before and my opinion is that their cookies are very good but they need more to survive where they are; indoor seating or maybe coffee. They may have those things now, but I haven’t been since just after they first opened.

Storybook was next on the B Street route and I finally surrendered to the sweets temptation and sampled the small caramel brownie on offer. I like Storybook, but the three times I was there the menu was the same. Good, but the same. I’ll go back and see if it has changed.

I passed The Bistro, as I live there most days. The Bistro is one of the premier beer places in California. It doesn’t look like much, but it's had a big influence on beer history. Beer Week was founded as a response to Vic’s (The Bistro’s owner) IPA Festivals. The Bistro’s IPA Festival is still the kick-off for Beer Week and Russian River’s IPA, Pliny The Elder was created for The Bistro’s first IPA Fest. Anywhere you are in the world, if you see a “West Coast Style IPA” you are seeing a “Vic-at-The-Bistro-in-Hayward-inspired” IPA. But time was of the essence today and, as I said, I live there.

Aqua E Farina is one of three Italian restaurants in downtown. Aqua E Farina served house-made gnocchi in a light tomato cream sauce and pasta in a pesto-basil sauce. Aqua E Farina occupies a shop on the ground floor of the old Green Shutter Hotel. The shop was a well-respected French restaurant many years ago, then a dodgy bar, and now a well-respected Italian restaurant. The main dining room is frescoed with scenes from a downtown somewhere in France with Italian wording overlaid on various shops. I thought the gnocchi was very good. My friend calls them, “little pillows of perfection” and they are. I have never had any luck with store bought ones, but these were wonderful.  

We walked past Nomi’s Cafe, for unknown reasons. I don’t know, we just missed it. We ignored Buffalo Bills too—it deserves an entire article since it has a display in The Smithsonian. It’s been bought two times since opening and the current owners also own The Mexican, Metro Taquero, and Casa del Toro.

But we stopped at T4, a boba tea and food place. I’ve stopped there for tea before and liked it but a friend mentioned their popcorn chicken, which is what was on offer. The popcorn chicken was good. I’d get it again. There is no sense that this is a place I’d go to and sit for meal. If I was at The Bistro and needed a bite to eat, I’d order T4's popcorn chicken and take it there.

Image of two dishes from Casa Del Toro.

We crossed the street to Casa del Toro. It's the upscale restaurant from Alejandro Gamarra, owner of The Mexican, and Metro Taquero. This was the first really terrific taste we had. We got two cups: one with prawns and polenta in a creamy sauce and the other with lobster broth & tomato sofrito. Both were excellent, with the lobster being a bit spicier. We made a point of going back there for brunch the following Saturday, for my birthday.

Crossing Foothill we stopped at a middle eastern snack shop celled Old City Roastery. This is the kind of shop you might find in Old Town Sacramento, or at Cannery Row in Monterey. They have several rows of sweets and one row of savory treats, like roasted nuts. If you want to support a sweets and treats shop in town, stop by. They are on the eastern side of Foothill between A and B Streets.

Aama’s Kitchen is a couple doors down and it was a treat. The serve Himalayan cuisine, and are very good. This is the proverbial hole in the wall restaurant that is wonderful. They served a butter chicken and a chicken momo—there was a vegetarian option, too. A momo is what I’d call a pot sticker: a small dumpling filled with….well they feature 10 different ones, all made in house.

You know the situation where you order an appetizer and the plate comes with 3 pieces and there are 4 of you which becomes awkward? Problem solved at Aama’s Kitchen, as the dumplings come 8 per order. I liked the place and plan to bring friends there. Be aware: this is not a black tie place. It’s a small family restaurant, but they make everything in house.

Speaking of glamour, Khao Hom across the street provides more of it. The interior is well appointed and they have an extensive menu which includes brunch. Their Taste Of Hayward offering was papaya salad with rice. I wasn’t as thrilled about it as I was at either Aama’s or Case del Toro, but the restaurant itself looked promising. I will definitely go back.

We didn’t go to Metro Taquero, feeling that we knew what they have to offer (great tacos) and Tang Jip is a vague memory too. They have electronic screens at each table to order from and I’m not a fan of that kind of technology. I like staff to come to my table, with their tablet, and say, “What can I get for ya Mac?”

We did stop by Cold Stone Creamery on the way home and, well, it’s ice cream—very good ice cream at that.

The three restaurants I want to go back to, and the three I would recommend, are Aama’s Kitchen on Foothill Blvd, Khao Hom also on Foothill Blvd, and Casa del Toro on B Street. The others were good but on this night, in this tasting, those three stood out for me.