Students and Teachers Concerned About AI In School
A HUSD teacher training recommended using Google Gemini to analyze student assessment data, causing some teachers to wonder if student data was secure. Public commenters felt the proposed AI Policy fell well short of what's needed.
Teachers and students expressed concern about AI to the Hayward Unified School District (HUSD) Board of Trustees during the October 28th meeting. A student characterized the proposed AI Policy as lacking in real content. Others worried about the lack of parent engagement and consent on the subject, especially regarding student information.
District staff tried to address concerns, pointing out that the policy was a mandated placeholder from the California School Boards Association, which should have been approved in January of this year. Trustees called for the policy to be revisited, with community engagement, and that robust Administrative Regulations be developed, as well. However, no date was set for that work.
Artificial Intelligence Policy
HUSD District Policy 0441: Artificial Intelligence was a Consent Item for the October 28th meeting. The two-page document broadly outlines how the District will approach AI tools. The document, which according to District staff is "generic language" passed down by the California School Boards Association, appears to condone the use of AI by both students and staff within certain parameters.
"[The District] recognizes the transformative potential of artificial intelligence (AI) to increase student access to information, support teacher effectiveness, and facilitate the administration of student assessments, as well as the potential for AI to undermine student achievement, health, and well-being. Therefore, the Board is committed to supporting the use of AI by students and staff"
The policy then outlines 9 guiding principles for AI use, including Student/Staff-Centered, Ethical Use and Transparency, Equity and Access, Community Engagement, and Continuous Improvement. The document appears to be intended to guide how the District approaches AI use from what could be described as a neutral stance. However, no actual guidelines for use are given, nor does it outline what is allowable or not.
The Hayward Herald is committed to bringing you the local news that affects our families and community. But we can't do it without the support of the community we serve. If you're able, consider becoming a paid subscriber.
These tools are already accessible to teachers, and possibly students, in HUSD. HUSD has maintained a contract with Google by which all students are assigned Chromebooks from as early as first grade. It's possible that some students are able to access the Google Gemini AI product through their Chromebooks. In August, Google revealed that it was turning Generative AI tools on by default to some schools using Google Classroom—a product which HUSD uses extensively.
A July press release from Common Sense Media outlines the results from a risk assessment their Youth Safety AI Institute conducted. They believe that the Google AI Search poses unacceptable risks to children, including missing clear signs of suicidal ideation, validating disordered eating, producing full answers to assignments, and unreliable answers to academic questions, with more than a quarter of answers citing forums and social media posts alongside peer-reviewed research. "The Youth AI Safety Institute recommends Google turn off AI Search features by default for accounts that belong to minors, and give schools and families controls for those features that don't exist today," the release says.
By the same token, the National Education Policy Center from the University of Colorado Boulder warns "Without effective public oversight, AI in schools will do more harm than good." And a report by the Brookings Institute warns that the risks of Generative AI likely outweigh any potential benefits it may bring.
Concern From Students, Parents, and Teachers
A student named Mateo, who spoke during public comment on the item, said that the policy has "no real accountability" and expressed concern at it being a mere one and a half pages long. He asked why the District hadn't implemented something more aligned with the Model Policy put forward by the California Department of Education, which includes concerns like Plagiarism, Disclosure, and Citation, Acceptable Use, Legal Compliance, AI Output Verification, and much more.
"Why don't you have a parental consent section in this policy?" Mateo asked the Board of Trustees. He urged them to consider adopting the Student-First AI Policy, which addresses things like what is unacceptable use, criteria for use, and a number of other more detailed topics.
Araceli Orozco and Maria Del Carmen Espinoza both expressed concern that an AI policy was being approved as a Consent item without full discussion or parent engagement. Both called out a lack of transparency and parent input on the development of the policy before the board.
Teacher Ricardo Gomez expressed concern about student information being uploaded into Google Gemini, as was encouraged during a staff training he attended. "I think that the policy that is proposed... doesn't have any real protections, doesn't provide any guidance," he said. He also urged the District to turn off any AI for students, at least at the Elementary school level. He said that his Curriculum Council has voted to ask the District to turn off AI for students at his site, but was concerned about a piecemeal approach.
Board Approves Policy As A First Step
Trustee April Eljeiroudi asked if there was any truth to the allegation that student information had been uploaded to Gemini. Mariana Solomon, Assistant Superintendent of Business Services, said that District staff "has acknowledged everything that has been spoken about." She said that the presentation was an example and that "no information that is detailed about our own students is in there."
Samuel Martinez, Assistant Superintendent of Educational Services, stressed that it was merely a training exercise. "We did not share data outside of people who have purview to that data," he said. Mr. Martinez attempted to assuage fears of the board. "That would be no different than a teacher using a Google Sheet and analyzing the data from their students," he said. He alleged that Gemini within the district is "internally secure" and is not used by Google for training purposes.
District staff said that the policy was generic language passed down by the California School Board Association. Trustee Eljeiroudi expressed concern for how things were handled. She said that policies usually have a process involving multiple committees. "I think any new policy cannot be on consent," she said.
"Unless it would make us fall out of compliance," Trustee Eljeiroudi said, "there's no reason for the board to pass this tonight." However, Superintendent Chien Wu-Fernandez avoided directly mentioning any kind of compliance or consequences. She said that the Policy was supposed to have been passed in January, but didn't mention why. Instead, she framed it as important to start the work on a real policy. "It allows us to have a grounding document to begin that work," she said.
Trustee Sara Prada expressed interest in having Google representatives come in for questions to "really demystify a lot of this for the community," she said. She also called for AI literacy education for students. "AI is not going anywhere," she said, "and it is a tool that if not understood and studied, can be dangerous." Trustee Peter Bufete liked the idea of having Google answer questions.
Trustee Austin Bruckner-Carrillo supported developing a more robust policy that included specifics, including what is prohibited and not, language to let educators deny AI use in classes, parent opt-outs, and AI in the workplace. However, he supported passing the policy before them if a more robust policy could be developed after. Trustee Eljeiroudi agreed that a more robust policy was necessary, even with an approval of the current one.
Though the Trustees unanimously approved Policy 0441, there was no timeline for when it would be revisited.
Comments ()